Faux Fireplaces: Your Thoughts?
Okay I seriously need YOUR help – yes the tables have turned! :) To faux or not to faux, that is the question and currently my new home dilemma. I move next week on Friday and I’m starting to think about decorating and how I seriously want to put a faux fireplace in this room below… but is that tacky? I was reading one of my favorite decorating books by Mark & Sally Bailey, Simple Home, over the weekend and they are seriously against it – that one must be true to the home and its history. I’m sure this home had a ceramic stove at one time, it was built in 1900, but that was long removed so now I’m trying to figure out if I should add a faux fireplace or not. This will most likely be my living room, though that is still under discussion as I have 3 different rooms that could all easily be a living room due to the incredible floor plan. But for the sake of keeping things easy, let’s go with this room being the space for the living room.
The wood herringbone floors are original (110 years old!), as is the ornately carved ceiling — you cannot see them too well in this picture but there are flowers carved in two rows across it along with beams… so it’s a pretty lovely living room. There are no windows on either side, but where I stood to take this photos there is a wall of folding glass doors leading into what will most likely be my office.
Anyway, what you are seeing in the back there are double doors leading to a very large tiled “wintergarten” that happens to be heated so I can use it year round… and out there I plan to cozy it up with plants and a place to read and relax. But back to the idea of a faux fireplace. I would look for something vintage — not new — but I think the real draw is to have a focal point but also to create something cozy — a mantle with a mirror above it and space below for stacking wood and some candles just seems like the right choice. But Mark & Sally Bailey would be against this decision, and so would a slew of other designers out there, yet I still want to do it. What do you think? Any tips? I guess I could also just buy a fabulous dresser or low cabinet and put a shelf over it and a big mirror on top but I have this fireplace idea stuck in my head.
Thoughts?
(image: holly becker for decor8)
Facebook
Pinterest
Twitter
Google +
Flickr
LinkedIn
September 20th, 2010 at 8:42pm
I think that if you feel a faux fireplace is right for the room, then you should go for it and forget what anyone else has to say about it. There’s an exception to every rule – like white after labor day! Plus you’ll make it look fab. I like the idea of a faux fireplace – good focal point in a room instead of a TV – frames up a piece of art, gives you a mantle to display a collection…
Hailey´s last [type] ..monday playlist
September 20th, 2010 at 8:42pm
So, my immediate reaction is don’t do it. But I’m having a hard time visualizing what you want. The only faux fireplace that I’ve seen is in my Aunt’s house, and no one wants their house to look like hers! Do you have any example pictures?
I do love that room though!! Those floors!!!
Becky D @ KingsDownRoad´s last [type] ..Vintage Pink Depression Glass Dish With Handles
September 20th, 2010 at 8:43pm
In general, I would agree with the statement that you should be true to the home and it’s history. But, I think a fireplace would fit extremely well within the style of your (lovely, lovely, lovely) new home. I would imagine it has had a fireplace somewhere in it’s past. I lived in a house from the same era in Amsterdam, and that had a fireplace….. So I would say: Go for it! But choose one in keeping with the style of the house. There is nothing like a mantlepiece when it comes to decorating. Still miss mine. (even though I love my new house).
September 20th, 2010 at 8:43pm
I personally love the idea! I recently bought a 1920′s mantle with the plan to place it in the living room of my townhouse, but my husband just couldn’t see my vision, so the plans got nixed and I sold it on Craigslist :( (I try to compromise with him on my design decisions). Anyway, I’d love to live vicariously through you! I think it’s unexpected and gives the room a focal point and some character. I say go for it!
Rachel
xoxo
Rachel @ La Bella Bungalow´s last [type] ..Be back soon!
September 20th, 2010 at 8:44pm
Holly,
Must first reaction was amazement that you would question yourself! While others, that you seem to admire, have their own opinions…I think go with your own ideas. You have awesome taste and a wonderful design eye! I might mention that YOU have a book coming out and honestly you would rock it! I also am debating this….so you do it and I will be inspired by you! <3
September 20th, 2010 at 8:45pm
OOPS It should be “My first reaction”…
September 20th, 2010 at 8:45pm
Truthfully, I think you could make a faux look really beautiful, and into something you will love. Which is my number one rule not only in my own home but anyone’s: You loving your home is your first priority. So if you’re dreaming of it, and you want it, and you’re willing to experiment with it, DO IT.
Besides, look at all those real fireplaces out there being used for something other than fires, right?! The rules are only good if they work for you. :)
September 20th, 2010 at 8:46pm
Don’t listen to others when it is something you want to do!
There are no rules…except this one: do what you love.
Can’t wait to see how you do the faux fireplace. I’ve seen some really great ones!
*bisous*
Dane
September 20th, 2010 at 8:47pm
Hi Holly! I know you must be beyond excited for the move to be this close! Yay! I understand the “be real to the home’s history” thing– but really, if you makes you happy, maybe the faux fireplace should be part of the home’s future history :) You’ve got to make it your home, not just the home that also belongs to it’s past…
Tricia McKellar´s last [type] ..Ease Bird in Flight- 8×10 Fine Art Photograph by Tricia McKellar
September 20th, 2010 at 8:48pm
I know a lot of designers are against it, but I never really have been so long as it feels organic to the look of the house. I like older looking ones that are filled with candles that can be lit and give off the look, if not the heat, of a fireplace. My parents have a newer model that has the fake wood to that covers the heating cans. I definitely don’t love that as much.
I like in 2 family house built that was built in 1890 From what we can gleam, there was a fireplace on each floor. They have since been filled with radiators and I long for the days when it still existed. Our apartment is on the first floor and the fireplace would have been in the dining room. Instead, we have a radiator that has at least been sunk into the wall.
I say if you like the idea, go for it. This room has a million possibilities. I can’t wait to see what you do with it.
September 20th, 2010 at 8:50pm
It really is all about a mantle… so yes. If you find a beautiful one to salvage, I think if done with taste and restraint, it can look great and even real. I have 3 fireplaces, none of them actually work. So really, what is the difference?
Lara´s last [type] ..Whole Hog
September 20th, 2010 at 8:51pm
I think you can easily pull off a faux fireplace without looking tacky. I say go for it! It won’t look like the tacky fake ones from the ’80s because of your taste and aesthetic. I’ve actually been thinking about one myself!
September 20th, 2010 at 8:51pm
I think a old vintage mantel piece would be lovely, (think of how the wood would create some additional architectural interest and texture) however, I would advise “gussy-ing” it up as a fireplace.
September 20th, 2010 at 8:52pm
I was thinking candles too. You could even do something of a modern-vintage mix. I saw a wonderful mantle I’ve been lusting after a while back that was silver (!) – that one was actual metal but you could paint a older wooden mantle any color. Another idea, which might seem not as “warm” but might really work is a collection of rocks with the candles in and around them –- to add some texture and height, as well as wax drip ease of clean-up. The other idea, I’m sure you’ve seen – fill the space that would be a “fireplace” packed tight with logs, all sawed off at an equal length (so the look it a box filled with the rounds of tree branch width get it?). Looks inviting but no fire involved. Let me know if any of those need elaboration – might be as confusing. Good luck!
September 20th, 2010 at 8:53pm
that is, advise AGAINST (gussy-ing it up!) as a fireplace
:)
September 20th, 2010 at 8:54pm
I would do it…as much as you respect other designers’ opinions…it is YOUR home, YOUR space. Lets face it….the function and look of fireplaces has drastically changed over hundreds of years from the neccessity of heating and cooking with wood, to coal, to prettying a room with gas and electric. I have seen many faux fireplaces and it is exactly what that room needed to add warmth both visually and bodily. In fact I might even go for something more contemporary as a bit of esthetic tension in that beautiful older home. I don’t know what else you are putting in the room, but I would do it and decorate seasonally around it.
September 20th, 2010 at 8:54pm
I would ask yourself why you want the fireplace. Is it for cosiness? If so, is there anything else that would give you the same feeling? How about a woodburning stove instead?
If it’s simply for providing a focal point to the room, here is where you could bring your personality and creative personality out. Why not something unique? Perhaps central could be a set of bookshelves: each shelf for a person living in your space and one for visitors to swap books – when they come, they are invited to bring something they don’t want to own any more and take one away. Or something else that is a talking point and interesting for visitors, that evolves over time and you smile at when looking at each of the shelves. Or a collection of old fashioned board games and a draughts/chess table as the centrepiece … whatever gives you the atmosphere you are looking for in your living room. Or even a fish tank?
September 20th, 2010 at 8:54pm
Sounds to me like you really really want a fireplace so why not, it’s not going to hurt the building it can be removed in the future as long as you put it in with care. I can think a few alternatives like a shelf or cabinet but they full short on the comfort factor.
I really see Mark & Sally Bailey view point but what’s right as a theory is always right for making a home. By the way your wood floor is amazing:)
Colleen Pugh´s last [type] ..felt good
September 20th, 2010 at 8:54pm
Hmmm?! I’m taking your BYW class, and you keep telling us to be true to ourselves and what we love. Does it really matter Mark and Sally have to say? It’s an architectural element that you love, so it seems pretty simple. Are you going to have it permanently installed or prop it against the wall like a found piece? I feel certain that you can make it work beautifully!
September 20th, 2010 at 8:55pm
go for it!!! its def on my home decor list–when i get my own place!
they make a room soooo cozy, lived in, glamorous, traditional!
i think they can transform an ordinary room into some awesome!!
September 20th, 2010 at 8:55pm
I do understand where the designers are coming from but…I don’t care. I say that you must have a fireplace, if not woodburning then the next best thing. You live in your home not just look at it like it has been set up for a photo shoot. If it makes you smile inside when you think about it then you should do it.
Sherri B.´s last [type] ..Reusable Canning Lids
September 20th, 2010 at 8:57pm
Do what you want to do. It is your home and it is supposed to make you happy. If a faux fireplace will make you happy, do it! They can look very tasteful, and there is something so comfortable about the sight of one.
September 20th, 2010 at 8:57pm
Decorating is all about personal choices and NOTHiNG creates a focal point in a living room like a fireplace and mantel. I think you’ll do a wonderfully creative job of incorporating one into your design plan. Whenever I hear someone say absolutely never do so and so, it makes me want to do it right away as I’m sure it’s got merit!
Georgianna Lane´s last [type] ..Ribbons and Bows
September 20th, 2010 at 8:57pm
a. It’s your house and b. I only think it’s tacky if you get a fake crackly fire. If you get a decorative fireplace screen or a candleabra or something like that to put in front (you could probably make one!) people won’t even notice it’s not real.
September 20th, 2010 at 8:58pm
Not sure exactly what you mean by “faux fireplace”…but I could TOTALLY see a mantle (appropriate for the time period, of course) along one of the long walls filled with candles for ambiance.
tiny.cc/rcsma
September 20th, 2010 at 8:58pm
Go for it! It is 2010, and your ‘home’ to be lived in and enjoyed the way you want , not a place to adapt to the way it used to be lived in for the purposes or lifestyles of previous owners– of a year ago or a century ago. Find a fantastic mantel and surround from an architectural salvage source or build what specifically will suit your desires. Line the interior of the firebox (sheetmetal worker can easily fabric what is necessary). Logs for gas burning fireplaces have come a LONG way in appearance so incorporate those along with containers of biofuel behind the “logs”. Denatured Alcohol is a very economical fuel to burn. It emits warmth, is clean burning, and the fire lasts typically 3 hours before ‘refueling’ — we’ve done this approach to existing fireplaces in clients’ homes where the existing fireplace was non-functional in the typical, wood-burning manner as the chimney had been capped off. Bottom line: It’s yours so make it your own — its very simple to accomplish! All the best!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:00pm
I think that whatever you put into your home you will make it beautiful. If you want a faux fireplace then go for it – it’s your house and you are the one living there. If you really want one and don’t go for it due to others’ style conventions everytime you look at the space you will think, “There should be a fireplace there”.
Can’t wait to see the finished home!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:00pm
holly, when i bought this house, it had a faux one already here which housed a gasheater, but not a real fireplace.
i love it in my house. the gasheater part was paneled over, so i recycled a broken wall mirror that a friend was throwing away and it made it a lightbouncer.
if your designheart tells you to do it, do it.
oh, here is a photo of my mantel::
http://www.flickr.com/photos/dawnhouser/3529502230/in/set-72157604820949537/
and rest of house::
http://www.flickr.com/photos/dawnhouser/sets/72157604820949537/with/3529502230/
congrats on your new place!!!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:00pm
I say do what you want. If you really feel torn, maybe consider getting a “shelf” that looks like an old mantle top…?
I think you could make a faux fireplace really sophisticated and not look out of place. It’s not like you don’t have a good eye! =P
September 20th, 2010 at 9:00pm
Dont be true to the house – be true to your own heart – even if it dosent make sense :-)
A faux fireplace is cool, it´s simple, it´s easy, it´s stylish…as long as you get a beautiful one with great design :-)
I would personally go for that one even though I live in an old charming house too!
Maybe wait a couple of days and if you still wanna get the faux fireplace on Friday – do it :-)
Hugs/ C
Ps. I got a virus on my computer so I´m writing on my hubs mac…sigh… I hope it dosent give me trouble with this coming week on BYW :-) I´ll have to wait a week to get it back!
I wish you a wonderful week dear :-)
September 20th, 2010 at 9:02pm
In my humble opinion, I think it might be a good idea to get an original copy of the plan of the house. That would show whether or not it ever had a fireplace, and if so, the position it was in. Working from this, you can then go to architectural reclamation yards and source fireplaces which are from the period the house was built in.
I believe they call this restoration, or having your cake and eating it too :)
xo
Ijeoma´s last [type] ..The London Design Festival
September 20th, 2010 at 9:02pm
I think you should rock the faux fireplace and show them how it’s done. Your new digs sound, and look, gorgeous! Exciting.
September 20th, 2010 at 9:03pm
I love the idea of having a faux fireplace! I’ve seen so many gorgeous examples which look stunning! One faux fireplace which I saw awhile back was stacked with books and it looked great! I say you should go for it :)
Ludmila {creamylife.com}´s last [type] ..Chandelier heaven
September 20th, 2010 at 9:12pm
I would love to see a vintage fire place painted white with a bunch of those tall pillar candles inside. I’ve loved that look for years and I would do it in a second in my own home if I found the right antique.
September 20th, 2010 at 9:12pm
I think you could make it work – especially if you find something funky and antique and that it is supposed to look like an awesome “found” object, RATHER than trying to make it look like you have a real fireplace there (don’t match it perfectly, with the white molding and decorative ceiling, and don’t build it out so that there is a big area underneath to “pretend” to burn logs.) It’ would be a great focal point and ad coziness to the room for sure! can’t wait to see all of your after pics!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:15pm
i love the idea. i have a really cool old mantle that i move all over my store and it really adds to the room. you can stack a bunch of books in it, stack logs in it or put beautiful screens in front of it. in the next room i’m using it in, i’m going to roll up all my kilim rugs and stack them in it like logs, can’t wait to see how it looks! i say it’s a DO!
hawthorne girl´s last [type] ..september issue
September 20th, 2010 at 9:16pm
@Jen – I just laughed out loud at your comment — “fake crackly fire” — OMG my friend growing up had a grandma with a fireplace like that, and it rolled these plastic bits inside I think and made this crackle sound and it glowed… Oh my I can’t stop laughing. Can you imagine having one of those – so campy right!? LOL.
September 20th, 2010 at 9:18pm
I love that you guys are SO rebellious like me because I totally want to break “design code” here and go for it. But I’m human and also double guess my decisions at time but I think I’m going to go for it and rock this fireplace. I was 90% sold on the idea for months now but your encouragement gave me that push. Okay so I’m going back to eBay to look through all of those antique fireplace fronts I bookmarked last month….
September 20th, 2010 at 9:20pm
I think a definite yes as long as you keep with the style of the house so it looks like it belongs. Who cares what those other designers say? I am a designer and have never felt that the new electric and faux fireplaces were tacky. (if you are planning on just hanging a fake mantle and surrounding some candles with molding I would be opposed to that but not to a fake fireplace) Check out the web…you may be surprised at the choices you have today.
Hope you post a photo of the completed project.
September 20th, 2010 at 9:21pm
I think it is your home and you decide how it is decorated. I say the hell(sorry) with all designers that say you can’t. Knowing you, you will make something special and beautiful out of it.
Marianne´s last [type] ..My favourite bag
September 20th, 2010 at 9:22pm
@Ann – Totally! Though we are human and even the best of us needs help and encouragement from time to time. :) That is why I love to ask my readers for their opinion and this is something else you can take away with you from your experience with me – never be afraid to show you are HUMAN on your blog. As you can see, plenty of lovely readers are jumping in with great ideas and support — this is what you need as a blogger, the ability to show you are not perfect. We are blog authors, people read blogs because they want to feel a connection and also see how the rest of the world outside of design magazines really live. So I’m showing everyone – this is how I live, my dilemma, my ideas… It’s good to just be yourself as a blogger!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:28pm
I think you should not have a faux fire place in that room. Better have some more bookshelves insted. There are more useful and look great too!
I hope you will let us know what you did in the end.
Love your blog. Thanks for sharing all the stuff.
Greetings ines
ines´s last [type] ..Sammelglas
September 20th, 2010 at 9:30pm
First thought – A large funky painting of a fireplace! That way you can get whatever type of mantle you want.
September 20th, 2010 at 9:30pm
I think that a fireplace, real or faux, is what that room’s calling for. I love the idea. Maybe it is a little bit tacky when you come to think of it, but many things are that we use to decorate, what matters is the end result’s pleasing, and yours will be. Btw, thats and awesome home you have there, im so envious!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:31pm
I tink you can totally pull one off.
LOVE the one here –
http://ashleyannphotography.com/blog/2009/03/19/downstairs-before-after/
tasha roe´s last [type] ..An Ashly Ann Inspired Baby Shower
September 20th, 2010 at 9:31pm
I had a faux fireplace ion my apt. and I thought it was fabulous!
It also gave me something to decorate at holidays.
If there are people out there who dislike them, they don’t have to have them- more for us!
Check local salvage places like Habitat for Humanity Restores for more choices in mantles!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:32pm
Do it. You have an amazing sense of design and will choose something that is perfect! Can’t wait to watch your new home unfold.
September 20th, 2010 at 9:34pm
you should be true to yourself! (and your home will come along…)
OrangeFarmhouse – Maike´s last [type] ..Rood met witte stippen
September 20th, 2010 at 9:35pm
The room is just gorgeous, and BEGGING you for a vintage fireplace…..wood, marble, limestone, something aged and beautiful…..The great ceiling height, those amazing floors and windows….you have all the components….but a great fireplace surround would look stunning.
September 20th, 2010 at 9:36pm
I agree Holly- we know design “rules” are meant to be challenged, so I say “go for it” too! I do agree that most older fireplaces can’t be used, so they just become a lovely place to safely burn candles anyways.
You can totally rock making this faux fireplace a testament to breaking the rules, so I think you should go for it. You will just have to make sure you let us all in on the finished look!
Oh by the way, your place is absolutely fantastic… those gorgeous floors, the ceiling, and all that light coming in those doors… and a wintergarten!? What a lucky girl you are… well worth all that time spent in that little apartment!
Congrats to you… start shopping girl!
Erica Cooper´s last [type] ..Off to the Creative Connection Event!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:36pm
Have a few custom woodworkers or craftsmen work up some designs for you to get some ideas. I just saw a mantle built on the show “Yankee Workshop”. The one they built would not be right for your space though. However, it can definately be done with taste and style while staying true to your home. I have seen some absolutely lovely faux fireplaces lately. The room you show could easily handle one as a focal point. I would go for it.
September 20th, 2010 at 9:36pm
When you can’t have a real one, and it is something that you really want. I say go for it! If it’s stacked with wood, who’s going to know (besides you and us) that it’s faux anyway? Seriously…just do it!
Leanne´s last [type] ..I made this!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:38pm
I’d go for it—follow your initial instincts—it doesn’t sound like you are trying to make this look like a “real” fireplace—ie fake flames,etc!!! Think of it more as a vignette or “wallscape” :) Although some designer’s may not like the idea—I remember something that has always stuck in my mind—a whole debate about pillows on beds–to have or not to have–many or few,etc..there were opinions that ran the gammit, but in the end I have seen beds that look great with and without alot of pillows! (I am a decorative pillow person :)
So, in summary, follow your initial instinct—the good news is that if you don’t like it a fake fireplace is easier to take out than a real one!! :)
Can’t wait to see your new place!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:45pm
FAUX yes!!!! If you want one then you need one. Just make sure it looks real. Build it out of great materials….do lots of research on the period of your home and build one that looks accordingly. Lots of houses had faux fireplaces originally…it showed you had money if you had a faux one with a gas heater rather than wood burning. A fireplace always makes a nice focal point.
I’d find a photo of an old one I loved and I’d duplicate it.
Please see my own post where I created a faux fireplace in my own home to replace the one that was taken out many years before.
http://modvintagelife.blogspot.com/2010/02/anatomy-of-fireplace.html
September 20th, 2010 at 9:47pm
I like the idea of fireplaces – even if they’re faux! They make any room seem much cozier. Although, Holly, this room looks spectacular how it is now with the radiators. I found a portable, modern and sleek fireplace here that might look interesting in this room: http://www.homedecorators.com/P/Loft_Portable_Fireplace/450/
caitlin of wanderlustings´s last [type] ..priscilla – pink and black colorful rockabilly cameo ring
September 20th, 2010 at 9:47pm
It sounds like you really want this fireplace. So why would you give a crap what others think? It’s YOUR home and YOU will be living there, not those authors who might disapprove (of course they’re entitled to their opinion but so are you!). To quote the lovely Clint Eastwood: “Opinions are like a**holes. Everybody’s got one and everyone thinks everyone else’s stinks.”
So by all means: just do your thang!
September 20th, 2010 at 9:48pm
* sorry, click on the alternative view for the link above to get a better feel of how it is set-up :)
September 20th, 2010 at 9:55pm
Dear Holly I would say that if YOU like it, then GO FOR IT!!! : ) : )
September 20th, 2010 at 9:57pm
do it!!!
beth cupitt´s last [type] ..Watermelon
September 20th, 2010 at 9:58pm
I vote yes!
I’d love to see all your inspiration photos… and of course the finished product. :)
Good luck, I’m sure it will be to die for, as always.
September 20th, 2010 at 10:00pm
Well, I do think one should have a home that reflects who they are and how they live. And, I also think that a person should have in their home anything they want if at all possible. With this said however, I have a specific opinion about fireplaces. A fireplace is meant for a fire. It was designed of necessity and function. So, if I had a client who was pondering the same question as yours, I would first discuss with them what it is about a fireplace that calls to them. We could then explore options. If a faux fireplace is what you want, then do it regardless of what others think. I would only suggest that you make sure that a faux fireplace will provide for you the feelings/mood/look etc., that a real one would.
As a side note, I love to watch HGTV House Hunters. Whenever a house is shown with a non-working fireplace, I think, “well, if it doesn’t work, I’d rather have the wall space.”
September 20th, 2010 at 10:01pm
My sister in law custom built a faux fireplace to display candles in, and it’s lovely. She had an exposed brick wall with one segment that jutted out and was drywalled – she placed the faux fireplace there and now it seems like a chimney instead of an eyesore.
For your space, I think a traditional square fireplace would only work if it had nice clean lines and not a ton of decorative details (they’d compete with the ceiling, I think). But I’m no expert :-)
I think that, regardless of what top designers might say, if you’d really enjoy the warm glow of candles or a gas fireplace to cozy up to on a chilly fall evening, you should go for it.
Diana´s last [type] ..Thoughts on Creativity
September 20th, 2010 at 10:02pm
Do it!!! This is your home, your space, your vision. I can see how a beautiful vintage mantelpiece would look amazing in this room. Can’t wait to see the finished place! LOVE the floors!
September 20th, 2010 at 10:06pm
Our house is about the same age (built in 1905) and had fireplaces and mantelpieces in almost every room. So there is a good chance they were in your building originally as well. We had most of the mantels restored in the original black marble and they really add charm to the place, even when the fire is not on. Also, I know a lot of houses in my neighbourhood that still have a mantel without a working fireplace and those have the same effect. So I would say yes, go for the faux thing, but I would order one in the style of the house (there are some really nice white pieces made in that period as well!) and place it in a logical spot (most mantels are located in the middle of the wall). Good luck!
Iris´s last [type] ..Anniversaire
September 20th, 2010 at 10:13pm
Go for it!!!
Hell, anything can look tacky if done. . . well, tack-ily. But you’d rock the heck outta a faux fireplace. And then you could hang stockings at Christmas!
I’d love to do it in my place, but my LR is just too tiny with too many windows.
September 20th, 2010 at 10:20pm
Hi – it’s Julie, from BYW class….I say go for it! Years ago, when a local hardware store was going out of business, I purchased a wood mantle set and put it together with every intention of adding the heating element the following winter. Needless to say 6 years later, i still have it and have moved it between my bedroom and living room at different times. I have a wreath stand with a large wreath sitting in the open space, and am starting to think about how to insert a small bookshelf in the space for more versatility.
Do it!!!
September 20th, 2010 at 10:28pm
Yes, do it!! If you want it then go for it. I got a faux fireplace made in my living room when I bought my house last year. I love it!
My Owl Barn´s last [type] ..Collection- Aqua & White
September 20th, 2010 at 10:29pm
I would say go for it!!! I love the look and wish I could fit one in my living room!!
September 20th, 2010 at 10:30pm
i would definitely go for it ! for me something like that would be an option:
http://www.car-moebel.de/docs/shop.aspx?domid=1087&id=38013&aid=171323&cid=705&search=true
car möbel are very popular in germany and austria and they have reasonable prices.
more:
http://www.tischlerei-boegelsack.de/angebote.htm
http://www.ecomoebel.de/liste_ecomoebel/moebel/102621.htm
a very modern approach:
http://www.impressionen.at/shop/produkt/Deko-Wandkamin/2431831
repeat: go for a faux fireplace – it will be so cosy !
September 20th, 2010 at 10:31pm
I have seen it done here in Buenos Aires and I have to say that it never looks “right” to me. It always looks Fake. I looked at an apartment before buying this one and it was gorgeous with high ceilings and wall to wall windows and plenty of molding .. very French in style, with a completely fake white marble mantle/fireplace on one wall in the living room. No chimney wall, nothing, it looked slightly ridiculous to us.
So I have to say that while a fireplace is wonderful, a fake is just a fake.
I hope you tell us what you decide :)
Candice´s last [type] ..Monday – Look At This Blog !
September 20th, 2010 at 10:31pm
I love the carved ceiling! What a nice view laying on the sofa :-) As for the faux fireplace…I used to be against them until one Christmas my mom, who lives in Florida, decided to add more of that Christmas warmth to our home. So she designed and built a fireplace out of cardboard and bricks! It added so much to the room, she later stuccoed it and added a tile surround and it still there after 15 years! Now it’s not only part of the house it’s nostalgic and charming, too! Holly, you have such incredible taste… what ever you decide to do will be beautiful! Listen to your heart and go for it!
September 20th, 2010 at 10:31pm
It’s your apartment, do what makes YOU happy…(as long as Thor’s on board with the idea also ^_^) I’m sure it will look fabulous!
September 20th, 2010 at 10:31pm
I have one. Love it.
Take a look! http://cgi.ebay.de/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=360277689671&ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT
September 20th, 2010 at 10:34pm
DO IT! Put what you want the way you want it in your house. You are so talented that I KNOW you can make it look as though it were there all along (or not, if that is what you are going for). Do what you want, make it beautiful and you will love it. Once you don’t anymore, just take it out! :)
September 20th, 2010 at 10:36pm
And yeah, I went through my large stack of LivingnMores this weekend – they’re so full of fake, ridiculously beautiful fireplaces. I’m so buying myself an antique mirror to hang over it and putting a nice vintage basket into it. Why would I care what some guys would say bout my fireplace? It’s fun!
September 20th, 2010 at 10:41pm
I wanted to give you my thoughts when it comes to decorating–especially the difficult task of designing our own spaces. I whole heartedly approach every project with the attitude that we have to take chances against what we might feel others would think is a bad idea if it will bring us joy, a sense of contentment or even just make a house feel more like our home. You should absolutely consider a fireplace in your living room, keeping the integrity of the space in mind and the happiness that it will bring to you and your husband. You have a beautiful sized wall that is calling out for a gorgeous focal point such as the warmth and cozy effect of a faux fireplace. When things are not permanent fixtures it is a great idea to give them a try, act on your urge and say, I’m doing this for me!!!
September 20th, 2010 at 10:41pm
Holly,
Definitely do what you want, it’s your home and ultimately everytime you look at that dresser, you’ll will envision the faux fireplace you should have done. It will make it truly “your space”.
September 20th, 2010 at 10:49pm
Hey Holly! I think a faux fireplace would be a great idea to give the room a focal point. I had a similar situation with a room that desperately needed somewhere to look to so I built one out of an old headboard I found in my grandmother’s basement. http://www.flickr.com/photos/pretendercrazy/4156254686/
September 20th, 2010 at 10:49pm
Yes, go for it! I can totally picture a fireplace in that space, and I think it would look lovely stacked with wood and really fit in with your aesthetic. I have no problem with a faux fireplace because so many old homes have ones that have been closed up. Plus, it’s so fun to style a mantel.
Jillian´s last [type] ..Daily Art Fix- Amanda Blake
September 20th, 2010 at 10:53pm
I say go for it! As others have pointed out, no “rule” should be set in stone. Listen to your own instincts– you clearly want one, so get one! And you’re also concerned about it looking tacky, so be cautious to make it as classy and beautiful as possible. I agree that candles are a stunning way to visually warm up the space and add romance. Just be sure to make everything about the fireplace real, except for the lack of chimney. In other words, use a true vintage mantle, and build out the fireplace using solid wood. You could even line the “firebox” and hearth with brick facing (real brick, but made in very thin panels) and extend the hearth out into the room a slight bit. The more realistic you can make it, the more you’ll love it!
September 20th, 2010 at 11:02pm
This room reminds me of many of the homes in the LivingEtc magazine and most have fireplaces. This room is begging for a vintage looking mantle! Please, please, please put in a fireplace!! You are so lucky to have this beautiful room with these awesome floors. Have fun and cannot wait to see photos!
September 20th, 2010 at 11:11pm
I say DO IT! I’ve wanted to do something similar in my own room, but I feel like that is too much work at the moment. (:
xoxo
Lydia Joy´s last [type] ..welcome to womanhood
September 20th, 2010 at 11:15pm
I say go for it! My only caveat would be that you should either be convincing or be more abstract with just a mantel. If you go for convincing don’t put it on a wall where you can clearly see that there is no actual firebox behind it – that’s a dead givaway, and try make it appear to be a real, but closed up fireplace with a tile surround and hearth or something to that effect. It’s that in between area that can get a little cheesy
Elissa´s last [type] ..Dont Forget
September 20th, 2010 at 11:17pm
Holly we have a living room with no real focal point (fireplace) so I am trying to make our view out the windows our focal point. Not what I’m used to. Anyway, NO on the Faux fireplace, it’s not you to do faux and you know it :)
September 20th, 2010 at 11:20pm
@susan g. – ha ha, okay you are funny but please it’s Tee or Thorsten (silent H) but never, ever Thor. OMG I laughed so hard at that!!! You are a riot!
September 20th, 2010 at 11:23pm
Hi Holly,
I think you should definitely do it. First of all if you feel it is something you want to add then go for it. Secondly, you may start a whole new trend of faux fireplaces and someone will read about it on your post and decide to do it too! :-) Thirdly, I cannot imagine you coming up with anything tacky or not absolutely beautiful so I know you can pull it off. I LOVE fireplaces whether real or not.
I think Benita at Chez Larson has a faux fireplace, doesn’t she? And we know she has great style.
Jacilyn
Jacilyn´s last [type] ..tiny
September 20th, 2010 at 11:23pm
@uschi – Yeah, I like the one from Car: http://www.car-moebel.de/docs/shop.aspx?domid=1087&id=38013&aid=171323&cid=705&search=true
But I’m still not sure — it may be out of scale with the ceiling height or look to “new” and I’m trying to avoid that so I may try to find something vintage. Let’s see!
September 20th, 2010 at 11:24pm
@Jacilyn – I don’t know, I have to ask Benita – I didn’t even know she had a fireplace. Where is it?
September 20th, 2010 at 11:30pm
@Ellen Bene – Yeah I guess it could come off cheesy NH/Phoebe-style design LOL huh??!?
September 20th, 2010 at 11:30pm
I love the idea of buying an antique fireplace frame and adding it to the wall!
You don’t need to carve a hole, just add the frame to the wall, and everyone will know it’s a savaged piece and not a pretend fireplace!
Don’t worry, we will not tell the guys from the book!
Besides, no matter what subject you talk about, there will always be the ones against it and in favor of it. You have such a good taste, go for it!
September 20th, 2010 at 11:33pm
Hey Holly,
do it! I did it 2 months ago and it looks great. Got mine from a German ebay seller: http://cgi.ebay.de/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=350359507003
Good luck with decorations
Katharina
September 20th, 2010 at 11:52pm
Yo want a fireplace, go get it girl :)
September 20th, 2010 at 11:56pm
I do not think you should not do something you want/love b/c of someone else’s advice, when it’s really an opinion. i do not think everything you do needs to be in the style of the house history itself. that being said I love this room of yours. I can see a fireplace looking good but I can also see it being beautiful without one as well.
September 21st, 2010 at 12:12am
Hi – i think the faux fireplace would be sweet – keeping it light, not heavy, as the room isn’t huge….and also, since it’s ‘faux’ you can always remove it – no harm at all in having fun, and making yourself happy!!
:)
happy for you!
September 21st, 2010 at 12:21am
If it’s something you want to do, then I say go for it!! It’s you who has to live in your home, not the blogosphere. :) A faux fireplace can look absolutely lovely as long as you get a piece that works with the age and character of your home. A well-styled mantelpiece could turn out to be the focal point that your new living room needs!
I’m doing a faux fireplace in my new digs. We should compare notes on the process! :)
Sarah @ Comfort and Joy´s last [type] ..The Rue Debut
September 21st, 2010 at 1:28am
wow…so many opinions about fireplaces! I live in a house built in the 1950′s and use the brick, “real” fireplace every single day once it starts getting cold. I LOVE fireplaces. If I were you I’d put one in every room – there’s nothing like fallling asleep, reading, doing almost anything, in front of a fire!
Mary Grace Thomas´s last [type] ..Vintage Aigner Heels
September 21st, 2010 at 2:28am
I say go for it! I’ve always wanted one for the same reasons you speak of. My tiny apartment doesn’t have a good wall for one at this time, but I’ll do it when I move into a place where it would work. Good luck with your move!
September 21st, 2010 at 2:50am
I think what you’re planning sounds GREAT! I can see why this home is just calling out for a fireplace…with the floors and all of the architectural details, it’s almost odd that there isn’t one. I can understand the reason why there is a “rule” against it, but in this situation I think it’s meant to be broken. We all know you’ll do it beautifully, and it will really focus the room. Our 1930 house has a fireplace in it that sadly someone bricked in, so it is now faux, but still a pretty focal point.
September 21st, 2010 at 2:51am
Do it! And here’s why… any incredible designer out there would tell you there has been a point in their career that they saw something done they had either a) never thought of, or b) previously been against… that they now adore.
Try it. Mark it out with tape first, and maybe even put a little lit candle on the floor:), and tap up a big square (where you may end up putting a large vintage mirror or something similar, above the faux fireplace), and live with it for a few days… see how it feels!
The Girl´s last [type] ..I Totally Wear Hats
September 21st, 2010 at 2:56am
There is nothing like the focal point of a fireplace (faux or otherwise) and there is so much to chose from – there will most certainly be something for your room (and as beautiful as it is, I don’t think it would be complete without such a warming element). Why not try something completely different other than the traditional and look at PLATONIC FIREPLACE CO – you might even like their ‘green’ range (www.platonicfireplaces.co.uk).
I’m a huge fan of Mark & Sally Bailey too and find much inspiration in their books and website. We live in the rolling hills of the Bega Valley in NSW, Australia in a large “shed” and I’ve employed everything from vintage, contemporary, recycled and modern to create our own style. We have a freestanding slow combustion stove and our fireplace surround is constructed from large timbers that floated down the creek at the end of our paddock which I then filled with white river pebbles! You’ll find something that will just sing to you and be precisely what you are after – it will be your space (with a touch of Mark & Sally Bailey!)
Have fun with all your plans – I don’t envy you – how do you narrow down your choices when you have so much inspiration in your daily life????
September 21st, 2010 at 3:43am
I say don’t do it. BUT, I bet you’d do a great job and make me change my mind.
September 21st, 2010 at 4:02am
Why not put in one of those gorgeous Swedish stoves? (kakelugn, I think?) So beautiful!
September 21st, 2010 at 4:02am
Faux fireplaces confuse me, however, I would love for you to change my mind! Perhaps it is just that I like real fireplaces so much that a fake fireplace disappoints. I look forward to seeing what you do!
Stef@hauteapplepie´s last [type] ..Happy Birthday HAP & Haute Pie Week
September 21st, 2010 at 4:03am
First of all, your floors are insane! I want them!
Second of all, I think if you got the right faux fireplace (vintage looking), it would look really great!
September 21st, 2010 at 4:35am
gutt response — your heart wants one, go for it. If anyone can choose the right fireplace to fit this space and the two of you, Holly can. I would love to see one here and cozy is all about you.
We LOVE our fireplace and it is not the focal pt of the living room because it is a corner fireplace and we have the TV on a wall adjoining this corner fireplace. We’ve decided to stop fighting the fact that the TV is mounted on the wall and not above the fireplace. imperfections have become my path to creativity.
September 21st, 2010 at 4:57am
Holly, I agree with nearly all of the 93 comments before me: Do it! You are skilled both technically and naturally in decoration. You know what works and what doesn’t. Something is telling you to do it…so do it! If it’s awful, you’ll change it. Break this “rule” and have the space that you want. You’ll love it!
Enjoy!!!
- Shari
September 21st, 2010 at 5:02am
sorry.. I meant to say was: I think this room is CRYING for a fireplace. It would be absolutely lovely. This is your home and should fit your lifestyle, no the other way around. Enjoy renovating!
Nat´s last [type] ..Fall Cooking
September 21st, 2010 at 6:04am
Go for it. If it is in your heart to do it than you should because if you don’t you’ll always wonder and secretly probably still want it – ha. You have such great style… I don’t think you could go wrong. And oh, those floors…..DIVEIN!!
xo Trina
September 21st, 2010 at 6:50am
I have no idea who Mark & Sally Bailey are, but one thing I know: if you like something and want it for your home, screw designers’ opinions – do whatever you want. It’s your apartment, not Mark and Sally’s, so you get to say what goes in it. ;)
Personally, I think this would look really good in an Altbau like this. Go for it!
Stina´s last [type] ..Versuch eines Rückblicks
September 21st, 2010 at 7:41am
I would LOVE to see one HANGING from the Ceiling!!!? It is a long room and anything sticking out from walls might be obtrusive… sooo not only will it bring attention to great ceiling it will be COOL to have a coupla chains hanging down with a great unique handmade funky fireplace ! Why faux? make it actually heat up someway ~ Use your imagination and let me know what you decide ~ either way go for it !
September 21st, 2010 at 8:30am
when i doubt-dont do it, BUT
if you doubting for others, then you doubting for the wrong reason and you should totally do it.
anything looks cool if done in the realest and personal way. You own decor touch will be revealed so go with the heart and stuff the rest! x
September 21st, 2010 at 8:38am
@Kimberleigh – Hanging from the ceiling? I have to see photos of what you mean, I cannot picture that at all. With chains? For reals?
September 21st, 2010 at 8:41am
@Bridget – Yeah we have those here — they are gorgeous! But you need to open the wall and install piping and such so that won’t work since we don’t own this place.
September 21st, 2010 at 8:41am
I never follow the crowd. How tacky ! I am sure you could incorporate it tastefully. As long as it looks beautiful..who cares! I would investigate if I could install a real one ! (finances taken into consideration) if I was to stay for a long time. Central heating has its place.. but the real thing is better. :)
September 21st, 2010 at 8:46am
Oops..just read you are only renting..dash THAT idea :) Didn’t the Victorians love a lot of faux things. Seriously..some designers can be a bit anal about things. I wouldn’t take it too seriously. Cheers :)
September 21st, 2010 at 8:56am
Holly, do it! You really should have a faux. I think it’s your new home and you have wait such a long time for it … it should have everything you dream of. I think an old german “Bollerofen” :) would look fantastic. And you can make yummy baked apple on it … hmmm.
caro´s last [type] ..Leave a comment and win!
September 21st, 2010 at 9:05am
I’ve seen a lot of faux fireplaces done wrong and they do compromise the spaces. If you’re trying to make it appear like a functioning fireplace, its the wrong idea. If done right, its more like art. In your space and with your style, I think it’ll look great! I say go for it! Especially if you find something vintage! Can’t wait to see what you’ll come up with, have fun!
September 21st, 2010 at 9:46am
Okkk well, think of your style….is it glass, metal, brick…. use that idea and hang it somehow or even from the floor ! I saw a great fireplace in Park City Utah once that was glass with sand, the flame as just a line (u could curve it, or make it square etc.) You see chandeliers right? So just make it to hang lower ~ I am not sure what your original plan was for the style of the room, so that would be important also. I will think on it more once I know what furniture style and pieces you would be using in the room ~
September 21st, 2010 at 10:27am
I am always against faux anything (except fur of course)… ; ) I would say if you put a fireplace in make sure it actually works… but that’s me… Can you not get a morso or something similar to work or is the chimney a huge issue? I think the room would be nice & cosy with a wood burning stove… and would not mind that it is more modern,,, I think the layers of living in a house in really important… as how do you choose which era is the right era to restore a house to? As long as it’s done sensitively it will be amazing!
I find that most spaces actually show you easily enough what it wants to be… and when one tries to do something different to what the space wants/needs it just becomes a struggle… ; )
Good LUCK!
Janine de Waal´s last [type] ..The jewel of Lusaka
September 21st, 2010 at 10:36am
@Kimberleigh – I still want to know — how do you hang a fireplace with chains from the ceiling? I wouldn’t do that but I’m DYING to know what you mean because this intrigues me now.
September 21st, 2010 at 11:29am
Well I think you should go for it…if its what you want then in the words of Tim Gunn on Project Runway – you can “Make it Work!”
I had one in a rental flat I had and it was great, its such a focal point in the room. I don’t have one in my current home and I miss it. Expecially in the festive season.
Oooh and I wanna see some pictures of the hanging fireplace…Kimberleigh more details please.
Leslie´s last [type] ..Inspiration All Around
September 21st, 2010 at 11:49am
I have lived in two old homes that had fireplaces that were closed off and inoperable so in effect they had become “faux”. What’s the difference, really? If it looks like it could have been original to the home, I say go for it. Many, many old homes have fireplaces that no longer operate. Yours just happens to be one that suffered the indignity of removal! I love your idea.
September 21st, 2010 at 12:08pm
Hi
What a lovely space and with a winter garden you are a very lucky girl!
Go for the fireplece….break the rules and prove the established thought wrong.
If at some stage you want to change it you can always put your vintage frame in the garden as a feature.
best of luck and thank you for your lovely blog.
Helen x
September 21st, 2010 at 2:16pm
Do it!!!
The worst possible outcome is that you won’t like it, and then you’ll change it and try something new (and tell the rest of us to stay true to the home and the room). The best possible outcome is that you’ll love, love, love it and be so glad that you didn’t let someone else’s ideals stop you from being true to your own sense of style (and tell the rest of us to trust ourselves and try something unusual if we feel it suits us).
Whatever you do, I can’t wait to see the outcome; your flat sounds like a dream.
September 21st, 2010 at 3:45pm
Hi
I am all for functionality, so for me the fireplace won’t do. A divine chest of drawers or another piece of furniture you can use as storage would be more practical and you can still make the space beautiful.
x
September 21st, 2010 at 3:51pm
Hi Holly–Love your always optimistic and joyful approach to life….so I am sorry to say I am not in love with this idea. As much as I believe you would make it look beautiful I can’t get behind a faux-place. I understand the mantle focus but your space looks narrow and I think it might be a challenge to balance it. And would you add a hearth? I live outside Chicago and we have long cold winters. I rely on my fireplace for a warm sparkling glow almost every early dark night, and it seems a shame to only have the suggestion of that comfort. Can you put in a real woodburning one? You won’t regret it.
September 21st, 2010 at 4:02pm
Okay…you definitely know what you want…you love decorating…it will be BEAUTIFUL if you do or don’t put in a faux fireplace. I LOVE fireplaces…and I have yet to live in a house that has one…they give us that cozy feel…they are beautiful…romantic…classy…I’m all about it…especially because you have an eye for design and decorating…you find the most beautiful things to post…so..go for it…it will look fabulous!
Brenda´s last [type] ..Izzy and her uniforms
September 21st, 2010 at 4:28pm
I say if it is what you want, then do it. There are always going to be instances when what you feel is right doesn’t resonate with others. You have to just tune out the noise and listen to what your gut is telling you. I hope you do it! And, if so, post pics!
September 21st, 2010 at 5:00pm
My first thought was whether the other appartment owners aren’t dreaming of a fireplace too – in which case you might be able to club together and reinstate the chimney. But I guess that is also a messy & expensive option.
I agree that a fireplace makes a great focal point, but I think that it really does need a fire, or something that looks like one.
I found one german company, Fredericianum, that does attractive mantles and also offers a gel-fire option (they call them bio-kamin). Check out http://www.kamineweltweit.de/
I really like a couple of their mantles but I’m now saving up for one I’ve fallen in love with from the UK.
September 21st, 2010 at 6:07pm
Holly,
I did not have time to read through every comment but I love the mantle that Virginia of sfgirlbybay installed in her new dining room. Is this what you were thinking about? I say go for it.
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2010/09/18/HOVS1F68IR.DTL
September 21st, 2010 at 6:43pm
@Amy – That is a fake fireplace in Victoria’s house? Are you sure? I thought everything in her new home was original?
September 21st, 2010 at 7:17pm
I emailed Victoria to find out about the dining room mantle/fireplace surround, it really looks like it is installed over the wall with no actual fireplace. Here’s a better picture. http://www.sfgirlbybay.com/2010/05/17/ive-gone-to-the-dark-side/
Amy´s last [type] ..Other Points West
September 21st, 2010 at 7:19pm
Holly- Here’s what I heard back from Victoria-
hi amy, it’s a faux mantel i got at ohmega salvage in berkeley and just drilled into the wall. it was quite simple! :) http://www.ohmegasalvage.com/
good luck!
victoria smith
writer/editor/stylist
Amy´s last [type] ..Other Points West
September 21st, 2010 at 7:24pm
I just scanned the comments and it seems like “Go for it!” is the majority opinion, but I still wanted to add my .02:
Who is going to live there? You or the Baileys? You! And it seems like you really want to do it, so go for it. As you quote in the BYW class (yes, I am a student), “to thine own self be true.” (Yes, I’m paying attention!)
Oh, and I just notice the comment above about sfgirlbybay. Yes — that’s a fake fireplace in her apartment! From the article: “To delineate the black walls, she erected a shallow white fireplace mantel.”
If Victoria can do it, so can you! :)
kelly´s last [type] ..One weird beer
September 21st, 2010 at 8:43pm
First, I think it’s in how you spin it. A wise jewelry dealer once said that if you wear it with confidence, others will believe in it, too. I think you, with your experience, could really pull it off. Second, if you really want it, and have the means to do it, it will probably give you a lot of joy. Personally, I think it would look good, too, so go for it. You will make it look awesome. No doubt about it.
September 21st, 2010 at 11:02pm
I didn’t weigh in before, because for once I don’t have much of an opinion. But I came back to read the comments — it seems as though I’m one of the few! :)
Brigitte´s last [type] ..Lessons on Hospitality Learned in the Southern Hemisphere
September 21st, 2010 at 11:54pm
@Kelly – ha ha, you are cute. But you are not quoting me there, Shakespeare said that – not me!!!
Interesting about Victoria’s fireplace, I thought hers were all real. I never heard her mention
that on her blog before. Maybe she’ll pop over and give us the juicy details.
September 22nd, 2010 at 12:03am
FORGET Mark & Sally…go with your gut instinct…if you know you have the money and the style sense, go for it. I’m sure you will choose something that already flows with the decor and architecture of your new place, which will go quite nicely.
:))))))
jennifer ramos´s last [type] ..Honey Pie Design Via Made By Girl
September 22nd, 2010 at 3:33am
I would definitely go for it! Our house was built in 1915 and I know it had to have had a fireplace. We added an old one from an antique shop and filled it with candles and a mirror to reflect the light. Very romantic! I love your floors! Good luck!
September 22nd, 2010 at 10:04am
Checkout euroflues – some great ideas for awesome designs !
September 22nd, 2010 at 2:11pm
I say go for it if you love it, it won’t look out of place if you buy the right one, which of course you will. However, I would decide whether it will be your enteraining living room or a more intimate sitting room. I love the fireplace, a real one : ), in my living room. But, it takes up a lot of wall space that I would love to use for extra seating as it is the room I enterain in more.
September 22nd, 2010 at 3:47pm
I’m ok with the idea of the fireplace. However, it has to look like it belongs there. It’s doesn’t have to look like a faux fireplace but like a real one and have to put it in the room in a place that makes sense for a fireplace. It has to be big (not those mini fireplaces with red bricks that are ugly!), and it has to be white. I’m ok with faux fireplaces like these, it not please done put it!! that room is sooo gorgeous!!!
September 22nd, 2010 at 5:28pm
You’ll make it work, I’m sure. You don’t seem to be someone who goes to a DIY store for a (ugly) faux fireplace. I guess you would search the world for the perfect ONE :) Go for it! (and if you don’t like it after all…just remove it again, it’s faux anyway, so much easier)
Btw: I’m soooo jealous!! Adore your floors!!!
Anna´s last [type] ..In need of some peace&quiet
September 22nd, 2010 at 5:42pm
Yes you want to stay true to your house and I’m pretty sure too that it would have had a fireplace originally – it had to be heated somehow right?
Most importantly a home is an expression of who you are. That’s why decor is always changing to keep up with our tastes and lifestyles. If you would like a faux fireplace then I say go for it! The candles, mantle and mirror would make an excellent focal point for a cosy living room. Plus as you have large doors on both sides of the room, it will need a focal point to keep it grounded as a room and not just a passageway with a sofa.
That’s my opinion anyway.
Lisa´s last [type] ..For the music lover
September 22nd, 2010 at 7:36pm
wow, just have to say I’m seriously jealous of those original herringbone floors. Love!
September 22nd, 2010 at 8:05pm
I think in most homes a faux fireplace is WRONG however your new PAD is historic and can totally pull it off!
New build= NO FAUX FIREPLACE
Historic Homes/Building= HELL YEAH!
xoxo
keighley
Keighley@thebellalife´s last [type] ..Quote of the Day
September 22nd, 2010 at 8:13pm
Absolutely! Faux Fireplaces have acome along way baby. Perhaps a few years back (given what was available) I’d have said no. But I was even admiring some the other day that I saw, thinking Wow, these actually look great. Luckily I have the real deal, so no need to spend money on one for me, but I think it would look great in that space. You should go for it! :)
Congrats on the place. Can’t wait to see some final pictures.
September 22nd, 2010 at 8:34pm
My friend do a “real” fireplace! Why the discussion of faux…why not put in a “real” fireplace. My suggestion is to find the fireplace mantel of your dreams (probably period appropriate salvage find) and the fit with a better quality gas log set and use a ventless gel system. They are odorless, smoke free, heat effiecient and environmentally friendly. Then you will have a real flame fireplace without the mess and without the difficult task of uncovering possible walled over chimneys and allowing you the freedom to place the fireplace wherever you want in the room. Given the period details of your house, I think a unique alternative is using the Victorian English “coal set” http://www.kamineweltweit.de/biokamine.php?section=alkohol
It is also alcohol gel insert. BTW, what a fun room to decorate!!!!
September 23rd, 2010 at 12:45am
I think it’s silly to design based off what other interior designers think. It’s their opinion. Not yours. Most of them are so opinionated they wouldn’t know a good idea if it hit them in the face anyway. I say go with what you want and what makes you happy. Who cares what other people think anyway?…But, then again, that’s just my opinion ;)
September 23rd, 2010 at 3:20am
I was going to suggest the same thing as confessionsofmothertheresa when I first saw your post on Monday but was distracted by a viral ad on another design blog.
Oops, I’ve digressed. So, have you decided which way to go? It’s nice to be able to enjoy a fireplace in winter since the days are much shorter. The romantic ambience might just speed up the baby plan ;)
Clean gel or ethanol fireplaces are quite popular design pieces in Australia. No chimney required, no mess, no cleaning and you can even take it with you when you move! A period mantelpiece over the loft portable fireplace that Caitlin suggested. It’s inexpensive and only the metal base makes it stand out as a modern piece. You can probably cover it up with stacked logs. Can’t wait to see the final pictures!
September 23rd, 2010 at 3:30am
Oh, Holly — I’m mortified right now! Yes, I knew it was Shakespeare — I am so embarrassed that I wasn’t more clear about that. I guess I should have said, “As you quote Shakespeare…” (not just “As you quote…”)
I’m just going to curl up under my desk now. :P
kelly´s last [type] ..One weird beer
September 23rd, 2010 at 9:04am
Put in a faux fireplace if this is your desire. BUT: I would go for a modern style. Do not try to imitate an old look. THAT IS REALLY TACKY!
My opinion!
September 23rd, 2010 at 9:32am
@Kelly – Why? I don’t understand!? No worries dear… See you in class! :)
September 23rd, 2010 at 9:48am
Do it – Rooms like those in your new home – in my opinion – always look wrong without a fireplace. No matter how beautifully dressed there is always that feeling of something missing. And after all, its your home it needs to make you feel happy.
September 23rd, 2010 at 5:17pm
Really modern gas fireplaces are very hard edged and cold. They tend to look very out of place unless you are going full on modern. I have to disagree with Karen on the “TACKY”. There is nothing tacky about going with a genuine period appropriate salvaged matel. Retrofitting it with a gel or ethanol fireplace makes sense and is easy to use. I would never consider an electric (or any other type) fireplace with out a real flame. I know that a real wood working fireplace is more romantic and certainly the elitist would have nothing else. But the real wood fireplaces have many drawbacks including dust, dust, dust, smoke stains to walls and furniture, the mess made tracking the logs in and out, and the purchasing and storing of the logs themselves. This is really the very essence of the form vs. function argument. I know many elitists with real wood fireplaces with carefully place the wood logs and then dust them off weekly never planning on actually burning them and creating the hassle that comes with it. A month from now with snow or ice and cold wind blowing, I will come home and flip a switch to beautiful gas fireplace. I will then cozy up with the day’s paper and mail and get relaxed and toasty. It is a quality of life thing for me. Do a fireplace and reject all the “tacky” comments.
September 23rd, 2010 at 7:16pm
I’m sure someone has already said this but here’s my $.02 –
We’ve all seen faux fireplaces go terribly wrong. But there are a lot of rooms that have what I call “very definitely not working” fireplaces that come with a home but were taken out of commission at some point. What’s the difference between that & you adding a fireplace? I think the reason FF’s fail is that they try to look real but are so obviously not part of the aesthetic of the space. Since you aren’t planning to use it heat your space you can design & build (or buy) whatever you find that enhances the room. Consider your options & if you see something you like – well then it will work!
September 24th, 2010 at 10:49pm
I have a faux fireplace and its the best thing ever. However, its vintage, partially rusty, with flaking paint and all, and seemingly made of pure iron which makes it extremely heavy and quite a workout getting up my stairs.
I’ll put a picture up on my blog, I found mine on Craigslist.
September 25th, 2010 at 12:59pm
Let me explain what I mean when saying that faux fireplaces look tacky to me: I find nearly ANYTHING new, that was made to look old a little bit tacky: Houses, furniture, mirrors, cars… Either a piece is old, or it is new. Newly built houses that have “period” details? Awful! New wooden furniture that was made to look antique in a factory? Cheesy! Asian sportscars that are imitating the shape and color of an old Jag? Such a crime!
So if you like the old style of fireplaces, I personally would take my time and find something original on ebay, craigslist or some other place! There are dealers that sell old fireplaces…
I personally also prefer old things. If they are original. If I can´t find something old & original, I go for something new and modern. Or for a piece with a timeless design.
September 28th, 2010 at 12:47pm
I’m not quite sure a faux fireplace would fit the original feel of the apartment. I’m living in Germany aswell, and my apartment is actually qutie similar to yours, what I think makes those apartments great is the real floors, the real molds and the great old doors. So continuing this original feeling I would suggest you try an “Ofen” not quite sure what the appropriate word for it in English, I guess it would be a stove or heater, some apartments still have the originals, but we installed one in our apartment using the old chimney…it gives a lovely heat in the winter and it just fits in the whole aparment like it’s been there as long as everything else.
If you are looking for antiques in Germany, you should check out the “Agra” Antik-Markt in Leipzig. It’s the biggest antique market in Germany, it’s at the last weekend of every month and (especially if you get there really early in the morning) they have the greatest stuff for the best prices…and you can check out Leipzig when you’re there, it’s the most beautiful city and lots of great stores with furniture and decoration stuff…
September 28th, 2010 at 2:48pm
Hi everyone! So, I’ve made a decision about whether or not to add a faux fireplace to my house. I won’t be adding one. I think I’ll try something else that will be quirky and fun and unusual instead but it won’t be a faux fireplace. Thank you all for being so honest – I loved reading through all of your opinions, so great and I’m sure they’ll be helpful to others who visit decor8 wondering about adding a faux fireplace in their home or not. But yesterday, after speaking to the granddaughter of the man who built the house, I learned that a fireplace never existed in this home so it would be a bit out of character to add one. They had ceramic corner stoves.
@Ella – THANK YOU for the “Agra” Antik-Markt in Leipzig tip. I’m going to look this up and maybe go in the Spring. :)
September 29th, 2010 at 12:58pm
Well I had the same opinion until I saw one in real life. I was thinking exactly the same like what;s the use of a faux fireplace. When I saw one in a friend’s home, just after the hallway, just in front of the doors leading to the living toom. It was filled with candles and vintage beauties, and it really was stunning. Of course even now, I think that it should be used very carefully.
September 29th, 2010 at 12:59pm
BTW, this is a great place to live. Your office will be super and the wintergarden too.